Meeting Results

Committed to connecting the world

Results concerning Recommendations

Actions taken on Recommendations, Supplements and other texts at the 7 September 2012 SG 17 plenary

a) Recommendations approved (TAP – WTSA-08 Resolution 1):

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
3/17	X.1054 (X.isgf)	Information technology – Security techniques – Governance of information security	Jungduk Kim	TD 3249 Rev.2	ISO/IEC 27014
4/17	X.1528 (X.cpe)	Common platform enumeration	Robert A. Martin	TD 3092 Rev.1
4/17	X.1528.1 (X.cpe.1)	Common platform enumeration naming	Robert A. Martin	TD 3091 Rev.2 Note (2)	NISTIR 7695 Note (9)
4/17	X.1528.2 (X.cpe.2)	Common platform enumeration name matching	Robert A. Martin	TD 3090 Rev.3 Note (3)	NISTIR 7696 Note (9)
4/17	X.1528.3 (X.cpe.3)	Common platform enumeration dictionary	Robert A. Martin	TD 3089 Rev.3 Note (4)	NISTIR 7297 Note (9)
4/17	X.1528.4 (X.cpe.4)	Common platform enumeration applicability language	Robert A. Martin	TD 3088 Rev.1 Note (5)	NISTIR 7698 Note (9)
4/17	X.1541 (X.iodef)	Incident object description exchange format	Kathleen Moriarty	TD 3112 Rev.1 Note (6)	IETF RFC 5070 Note (9)
4/17	X.1580 (X.rid)	Real-time inter-network defense	Kathleen Moriarty	TD 3109 Rev.1 Note (7)	IETF RFC 6545 Note (9)
4/17	X.1581 (X.ridt)	Transport of real-time inter-network defense messages	Kathleen Moriarty	TD 3110 Rev.1 Note (8)	IETF RFC 6546 Note (9)
10/17	X.1254 (X.eaa)	Entity authentication assurance framework	Richard Brackney	TD 3247 Rev.3	ISO/IEC 29115 Note (10)
Notes: (2) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 48 Annex D Attachment 3) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1528.1. (3) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 48 Annex D Attachment 4) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1528.2. (4) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 48 Annex D Attachment 5) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1528.3. (5) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 48 Annex D Attachment 6) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1528.4. (6) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 40 Annex D Attachment 2) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1541. (7) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 48 Annex D Attachment 7) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1580. (8) WP1/17 Report (COM 17 – R 48 Annex D Attachment 8) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1581. (9) Related text. (10) Related text (neither common nor twin text) Approval of the above Recommendations is reflected in TSB Circular 310 of 11 September 2012.

b) Recommendations discontinued (not approved) (TAP – WTSA-08 Resolution 1):

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
2/17	X.1037 (X.rev) (Note 2)	Architectural systems for security controls for preventing fraudulent activities in public carrier networks	Roman Khokhlov	TD 2610 Rev.2
4/17	X.1527 (X.xccdf) Note (3)	Extensible configuration checklist description format	Robert A. Martin	TD 3101	NISTIR 7275 Note (4)
Notes: (2) Draft X.1037 (X.rev) was decided to be discontinued; the text was converted into a Supplement (X.Suppl.16) and agreed to (see c) below). (3) Draft X.1527 (X.xccdf) was decided to be discontinued. (4) Related text. Discontinuation of draft Recommendations ITU-T X.1037 and X.1527 are reflected in TSB Circular 310 of 11 September 2012.

c) Supplements and Appendices agreed:

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
2/17	X.Suppl.15 (X.ncns-1)	Supplement to ITU-T X-series Recommendations – X.800-X.849 series – Supplement on guidance for creating national IP-based public network security center for developing countries	Dmitry Kostrov	TD 3154 Rev.1 Note (2)
2/17	X.Suppl.16 (X.rev)	Supplement to ITU-T X-series Recommendations – X.800-X.849 series – Supplement on architectural systems for security controls for preventing fraudulent activities in public carrier networks	Roman Khokhlov	TD 3163 Rev.2
3/17	X.Suppl.13	Supplement to ITU-T X.1051 – Supplement on information security management users’ guide for Recommendation ITU-T X.1051	Koji Nakao, Wataru Senga	TD 3118 Rev.2
4/17	X.1500 Amd.2	Overview of cybersecurity information exchange – Amendment 2 – Revised structured cybersecurity information exchange techniques	Youki Kadobayashi	TD 3167 Rev.2
5/17	X.Suppl.14 (X.ics)	Supplement to ITU-T X.1243 – Supplement on a practical reference model for countering email spam using botnet information	Yoo Jae Won, Hongbin Zhang, Bei Zhao	TD 3120 Rev.2
7/17	X.Suppl.17 (X.websec-4)	Supplement to ITU-T X-series Recommendations – ITU-T X.1143 – Supplement on threats and security objectives for enhanced web-based telecommunication service	Jae Hoon Nah, DaeHee Seo	TD 3253 Rev.1 Note (2)
Note: (2) It was agreed to change “requirement” to “guidance”.

d) Recommendations determined (TAP – WTSA-08 Resolution 1):

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
4/17	X.1526 (X.oval)	Open vulnerability and assessment language	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 64
4/17	X.1544 (X.capec)	Common attack pattern enumeration and classification	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 65
6/17	X.1126 (X.msec-6)	Security aspects of smartphones	Hongwei Luo, Yutaka Miyake	COM 17 – R 67
7/17, (10/17)	X.1154 (X.sap-4)	General framework of combined authentication on multiple identity service provider environments	Tadashi Kaji, Hyung-jin Lim	COM 17 – R 68
Notes: These Recommendations were issued as COM 17 – R 64, COM 17 – R 65, COM 17 – R 67, and COM 17 – R 68. Information on the Member States consultation is available in TSB Circular 311 issued 27 September 2012. Summaries for these draft Recommendations are given in COM 17 – R 62 Annex H.

e) Recommendations consented for Last Call (AAP – Recommendation ITU-T A.8):

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
6/17	X.1196 (X.iptvsec-6)	Framework for the downloadable service and content protection system in the mobile Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) environment	Heung-Youl Youm	TD 3188 Rev.1 Note (2)
6/17	X.1313 (X.usnsec-3)	Security requirements for wireless sensor network routing	Mijoo Kim	TD 3185 Rev.1
7/17	X.1164 (X.p2p-4)	Use of service providers’ user authentication infrastructure to implement public key infrastructure for peer-to-peer networks	Ayumu Kubota, Yutaka Miyake	TD 3082
11/17	E.115 (2010) Cor.1	Computerized directory assistance – Corrigendum 1	Erik Andersen	TD 3079
11/17	X.500 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory: Overview of concepts, models and services	Erik Andersen	TD 3070	ISO/IEC 9594-1
11/17	X.501 (2008) Cor.3	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory: models – Technical Corrigendum 3	Erik Andersen	TD 3064	ISO/IEC 9594-2:2008 Cor.3
11/17	X.501 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Models	Erik Andersen	TD 3071 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-2
11/17	X.509 (2008) Cor.3	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Public-key and attribute certificate frameworks – Technical Corrigendum 3	Erik Andersen	TD 3068	ISO/IEC 9594-8:2008 Cor.3
11/17	X.509 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Public-key and attribute certificate frameworks	Erik Andersen	TD 3072 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-8
11/17	X.511 (2008) Cor.3	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Abstract service definition – Technical Corrigendum 3	Erik Andersen	TD 3065	ISO/IEC 9594-3:2008 Cor.3
11/17	X.511 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Abstract Service Definition	Erik Andersen	TD 3073 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-3
11/17	X.518 (2008) Cor.2	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Procedures for distributed operation – Technical Corrigendum 2	Erik Andersen	TD 3066 Rev.2	ISO/IEC 9594-4:2008 Cor.2
11/17	X.518 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Procedures for Distributed Operations	Erik Andersen	TD 3074 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-4
11/17	X.519 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Protocols	Erik Andersen	TD 3075 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-5
11/17	X.520 (2008) Cor.3	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Selected Attribute types – Technical Corrigendum 3	Erik Andersen	TD 3067	ISO/IEC 9594-6:2008 Cor.3
11/17	X.520 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Selected Attribute Types	Erik Andersen	TD 3076 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-6
11/17	X.521 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Selected object classes	Erik Andersen	TD 3077 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-7
11/17	X.525 (seventh edition)	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory – Replication	Erik Andersen	TD 3078 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 9594-9
12/17	X.667	Information technology –Procedures for the operation of object identifiers registration authority: Generation of Universally Unique Identifiers (UUIDs) and their use in object identifiers	Olivier Dubuisson	TD 3083 Rev.3	ISO/IEC 9834-8
13/17	Z.104 Amd.1	Data and action language in SDL-2010 – Amendment 1: Annex C – Language Binding	Rick Reed	TD 2951 Rev.4
13/17	Z.109 Amd.1	Unified modeling language (UML) profile for SDL-2010: Amendment 1: Appendix I – Example language specification	Thomas Weigert	TD 2984 Rev.5
13/17	Z.151	User requirements notation (URN) – Language definition	Daniel Amyot	TD 3121 Rev.1
Notes: (2) WP2/17 Report (COM 17 – R 66 Annex A Attachment 1) contains the A.5 justification information for draft new Recommendation ITU-T X.1196. (3) Draft Recommendations ITU-T X.1196, X.1313, X.1164, E.115 Cor.1, X.501 (2008) Cor.3, X.509 (2008) Cor.3, X.509 (2008) Cor.3, X.511 (2008) Cor.3, X.518 (2008) Cor.2, X.520 (2008) Cor.3, X.500, X.501, X.509, X.511, X.518, X.519, X.520, X.521, X.525, X.667, Z.104 (2011) Amd.1, and Z.151 were sent to AAP Last Call #90 on 16 September 2012. No comments were received by the deadline on 13 October 2012 on those 21 texts; and X.1196, X.1313, X.1164, E.115 Cor.1, X.501 (2008) Cor.3, X.509 (2008) Cor.3, X.509 (2008) Cor.3, X.511 (2008) Cor.3, X.518 (2008) Cor.2, X.520 (2008) Cor.3, X.500, X.501, X.509, X.511, X.518, X.519, X.520, X.521, X.525, Z.104 (2011) Amd.1, and Z.151 21 texts were approved as announced in AAP-92 dated 16 October 2012. X.667 was placed into Last Call Judgment as announced in AAP-92 dated 16 October 2012. Summaries for these draft Recommendations are given in COM 17 – R 62 Annex H.