Page 32 - U4SSC Guiding principles for artificial intelligence in cities

Centralized Decentralized Hybrid

Execution A single city agency Each city agency (entity) A single city agency (entity)
(entity) takes responsibility takes responsibility takes responsibility for
for implementing the for implementing the implementing the “Guiding
“Guiding Principles for “Guiding Principles Principles for AI” for a set
AI” for all city agencies for AI” its own agency of city agencies (entities);
(entities) (entity) additionally, some
city agencies (entities)
Note: This option Note: This option take responsibility for
empowers a single city empowers all city implementing the “Guiding
agency to implement agencies to implement Principles for Ai” applicable
the Guiding principles the Guiding principles to their own agencies
for AI; however, it can for AI; however, it can (entities)
pose difficulties in terms pose difficulties in terms
of understanding and of understanding and Note: This option
implementing all city implementing principles empowers a single city
agencies’ requirements at each and every city agency as well as other
and delivering them in a agency and finding the city agencies (entities) to
timely manner right talent in each and implement the Guiding
every city agency principles for AI; however,
it can compromise
achieving a coherent single
implementation approach
at the city level
Compliance A single city agency Each city agency (entity) A single city agency (entity)
(entity) takes responsibility takes responsibility for takes responsibility for
for assessing compliance assessing compliance assessing compliance with
with the “Guiding with the “Guiding the “Guiding Principles for
Principles for AI” which Principles for AI” which AI” which are applicable
are applicable to city are applicable to its own to a set of city agencies
agencies (entities) agency (entity) only (entities); additionally,
some agencies can assess
Note: This option Note: This option gives compliance with their own
empowers a single more flexibility to city “Guiding Principles for AI”
city agency to assess agencies to assess which are applicable to
compliance at the city their own compliance; them only
level; however, it may however, it potentially
pose difficulties in terms compromises achieving Note: This option gives
of conducting all city a coherent single more flexibility to a subset
agencies’ (entities’) assessment approach at of city agencies to assess
compliance in an efficient the city level their own compliance
and effective manner with the set of principles;
however, it compromises
achieving a coherent single
assessment approach at the
city level
Each city, depending on its own context, particular constraints, and specific considerations, may
determine its own governance approach for regulation, execution and compliance of the “Guiding
Principles for AI”.

22