Meeting Results

Committed to connecting the world

Results concerning Recommendations

Actions taken on Recommendations, Supplements and other texts at the 2 March 2012 SG 17 plenary

a) Recommendations approved (TAP – WTSA-08 Resolution 1):

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
4/17, (12/17)	X.1500.1 (X.cybex.1)	Procedures for the registration of arcs under the object identifier (OID) arc for cybersecurity information exchange	Olivier Dubuisson, Anthony Rutkowski	COM 17 – R 42
4/17	X.1524 (X.cwe)	Common weakness enumeration (CWE)	Robert A. Martin	TD 2614 Rev.2
Approval of the above Recommendations is reflected in TSB Circular 268 of 8 March 2012

b) Recommendations not approved (TAP – WTSA-08 Resolution 1):

Q.	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
2/17	X.1037 (X.rev) (Note 2)	Architectural systems for security controls for preventing fraudulent activities in public carrier networks	Roman Khokhlov	TD 2610 Rev.2
4/17	X.1541 (X.iodef) (Note 3)	Incident object description exchange format	Kathleen Moriarty	TD 2624 Rev.3
10/17	X.1261 (X.EVcert) (Note 4)	Extended validation certificate framework (EVcert)	Anthony Rutkowski	COM 17 – R 30	CA/Browser Forum EVcert specification
Note 2 - Draft X.1037 will progress further on. Note 3 - Draft X.1541 has been re-determined and will progress further on. Note 4 - Draft X.1261 (X.EVcert) is discontinued. Non-approval of draft Recommendations ITU-T X.1037, X.1261 and X.1541 are reflected in TSB Circular 268 of 8 March 2012.

c) Recommendations determined (TAP – WTSA-08 Resolution 1):

Q	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
3/17	X.1054 (X.isgf)	Information technology – Security techniques – Governance of information security	Jungduk Kim	COM 17 – R 49	ISO/IEC 27014
4/17	X.1527 (X.xccdf)	Extensible configuration checklist description format	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 50
4/17	X.1528 (X.cpe)	Common platform enumeration	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 51
4/17	X.1528.1 (X.cpe.1)	Common platform enumeration naming	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 52
4/17	X.1528.2 (X.cpe.2)	Common platform enumeration name matching	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 53
4/17	X.1528.3 (X.cpe.3)	Common platform enumeration dictionary	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 54
4/17	X.1528.4 (X.cpe.4)	Common platform enumeration applicability language	Robert A. Martin	COM 17 – R 55
4/17	X.1541 (X.iodef)	Incident object description exchange format	Kathleen Moriarty	COM 17 – R 56
4/17	X.1580 (X.rid)	Real-time inter-network defense	Kathleen Moriarty	COM 17 – R 57	IETF RFC 6545
4/17	X.1581 (X.ridt)	Transport of real-time inter-network defense messages	Kathleen Moriarty	COM 17 – R 58	IETF RFC 6546
10/17	X.1254 (X.eaa)	Information technology — Security techniques — Entity authentication assurance framework	Richard Brackney	COM 17 – R 61	ISO/IEC 29115
These Recommendations were issued as COM 17 – R 49, COM 17 – R 50, COM 17 – R 51, COM 17 – R 52, COM 17 – R 54, COM 17 – R 55, COM 17 – R 56, COM 17 – R 57, COM 17 – R 58 and COM 17 – R 61. Information on the Member States consultation is available in TSB Circular 269 issued 8 March 2012.

d) Recommendations consented for Last Call (AAP – Recommendation ITU-T A.8):

Q	Recommendation ITU-T (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
6/17	X.1194 (X.iptvsec-4)	Algorithm selection scheme for service and content protection (SCP) descrambling	Jongyoul Park	TD 2644 Rev.1
6/17	X.1197 (X.iptvsec-7)	Guidelines on criteria for selecting cryptographic algorithms for IPTV service and content protection	Seokung Yoon, HeungYoul Youm	TD 2716 Rev.5
9/17	X.1086 Amd.1	Telebiometrics protection procedures – Part 1: A guideline to technical and managerial countermeasures for biometric data security – Amendment 1:Multibiometric protection procedures	Inja Jun, Hakil Kim	TD 2760
9/17	X.1091 (X.gep)	A guideline for evaluating telebiometric template protection techniques	Yoshiaki Isobe, Tetsushi Ohki	TD 2753
11/17	X.501 (2005) Cor.4	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Models – Technical Corrigendum 4	Erik Andersen	TD 2680	ISO/IEC 9594-2:2005 Cor.4
11/17	X.501 (2008) Cor.2	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Models – Technical Corrigendum 2	Erik Andersen	TD 2679	ISO/IEC 9594-2:2008 Cor.2
11/17	X.509 (2005) Cor.4	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Public-key and attribute certificate frameworks – Technical Corrigendum 4	Erik Andersen	TD 2682	ISO/IEC 9594-8:2005 Cor.4
11/17	X.509 (2008) Cor.2	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Public-key and attribute certificate frameworks – Technical Corrigendum 2	Erik Andersen	TD 2681	ISO/IEC 9594-8:2008 Cor.2
11/17	X.511 (2005) Cor.4	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory: Abstract service definition – Technical Corrigendum 4	Erik Andersen	TD 2684	ISO/IEC 9594-3:2005 Cor.4
11/17	X.511 (2008) Cor.2	Information technology – Open Systems Interconnection – The Directory: Abstract service definition – Technical Corrigendum 2	Erik Andersen	TD 2683	ISO/IEC 9594-3:2008 Cor.2
11/17	X.519 (2005) Cor.3	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Protocol specifications – Technical Corrigendum 3	Erik Andersen	TD 2686	ISO/IEC 9594-5:2005 Cor.3
11/17	X.519 (2008) Cor.2	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Protocol specifications – Technical Corrigendum 2	Erik Andersen	TD 2685	ISO/IEC 9594-5:2008 Cor.2
11/17	X.520 (2005) Cor.4	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Selected attribute types – Technical Corrigendum 4	Erik Andersen	TD 2688	ISO/IEC 9594-6:2005 Cor.4
11/17	X.520 (2008) Cor.2	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Selected attribute types – Technical Corrigendum 2	Erik Andersen	TD 2687	ISO/IEC 9594-6:2008 Cor.2
11/17	X.521 (2005) Cor.1	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Selected object classes – Technical Corrigendum 1	Erik Andersen	TD 2690	ISO/IEC 9594-7:2005 Cor.1
11/17	X.521 (2008) Cor.1	Information technology – Open systems interconnection – The Directory: Selected object classes – Technical Corrigendum 1	Erik Andersen	TD 2689	ISO/IEC 9594-7:2008 Cor.1
12/17	X.691 Cor.2	Information technology – ASN.1 encoding rules: Specification of Packed Encoding Rules (PER) – Technical Corrigendum 2	Jean-Paul Lemaire	TD 2522 Rev.1	ISO/IEC 8825-2 Cor.2
13/17	Z.107	Specification and Description Language: Object-oriented data in SDL 2010	Thomas Weigert	TD 2537 Rev.5
13/17	Z.109 (revised)	UML Profile for SDL-2010	Alexander Kraas	TD 2353 Rev.6
13/17	Z.151 Cor.1	User requirements notation (URN) – Language definition – Technical Corrigendum 1	Daniel Amyot	TD 2619 Rev.2
14/17	Z.161 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 core language	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-1
14/17	Z.161.1	The Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 language extensions: Support of interfaces with continuous signals	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 202 786
14/17	Z.164 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 operational semantics	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-4
14/17	Z.165 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 runtime interface (TRI)	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-5
14/17	Z.165.1	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 extension package: Extended TRI	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 202 789
14/17	Z.166 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 control interface (TCI)	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-6
14/17	Z.167 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 mapping from ASN.1	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-7
14/17	Z.168 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 mapping from CORBA IDL	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-8
14/17	Z.169 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 mapping from XML data definition	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-9
14/17	Z.170 (revised)	Testing and Test Control Notation version 3: TTCN-3 documentation comment specification	Dieter Hogrefe	TD 2590 Note (4)	ETSI ES 201 873-10
Draft Recommendations ITU-T X.1194, X.1197, X.1086 Amd.1, X.1091, X.501 (2005) Cor.4, X.501 (2008) Cor.2, X.509 (2005) Cor.4, X.509 (2008) Cor.2, X.511 (2005) Cor.4, X.511 (2008) Cor.2, X.519 (2005) Cor.3, X.519 (2008) Cor.2, X.520 (2005) Cor.4, X.520 (2008) Cor.2, X.521 (2005) Cor.1, X.521 (2008) Cor.1, and X.691 Cor.2 were sent to AAP Last Call #78 on 16 March 2012. One comment was received on X.1194 which was resolved and approved by the deadline on 12 April 2012. No comments were received by the deadline on 12 April 2012 on other 16 texts which were approved as announced in AAP-80 dated 16 April 2012. Draft Recommendations ITU-T Z.107, Z.109, and Z.151 Cor.1 were sent to AAP Last Call #79 on 1 April 2012. No comments were received by the deadline on 28 April 2012 and Recommendations ITU-T Z.107, Z.109, and Z.151 Cor.1 were approved as announced in AAP-81 dated 1 May 2012. Draft Recommendations Z.161 revised, Z.161.1, Z.164 revised, Z.165 revised, Z.165.1, Z.166 revised, Z.167 revised, Z.168 revised, Z.169 revised, Z.170 revised were sent to AAP Last Call #81 on 1 May 2012. Note 4 - Z.161revised, Z.161.1, Z.164 revised, Z.165 revised, Z.165.1, Z.166 revised, Z.167 revised, Z.168 revised, Z.169 revised, Z.170 revised have been consented using TD 2590 with the expectation that the editor further develops final text acceptable to TSB on the basis of TD 2751 prior to AAP Last Call. Draft Recommendations Z.161, Z.161.1, Z.164 revised, Z.165 revised, Z.166 revised, Z.167 revised, Z.168 revised, Z.169 revised and Z.170 revised were sent to AAP Last Call #81 on 1 May 2012. No comments were received by the deadline on 28 May 2012 and the 10 ITU-T Z-series texts were approved as announced in AAP 84 dated 16 June 2012.

e) Supplements and Appendices approved:

Q	Supplement (Acronym)	Title	Editor(s)	Location of Text	Equivalent e.g., ISO/IEC
4/17	X.1500 Appendix I	Overview of cybersecurity information exchange – Appendix I: Structured cybersecurity information exchange techniques	Anthony M. Rutkowski	TD 2757 Rev.1
5/17	X.Suppl.12 (X.oacms)	Supplement 12 to ITU-T X-series Recommendations – ITU-T X.1240 – Overall aspects of countering mobile messaging spam	Min Huang, Junjie Xia, Linlin Zhang	TD 2754 Rev.1