Page 112 - ITU Journal - ICT Discoveries - Volume 1, No. 2, December 2018 - Second special issue on Data for Good

ITU JOURNAL: ICT Discoveries, Vol. 1(2), December 2018

Much of Harari’s vision mentioned at the outset is [5] German Ethics Council. Big Data and Health.
dystopian. He argues that the merging of ICT and Data Sovereignty as the Shaping of
biotechnology has already given us the ability to Informational Freedom (Executive Summary
“hack” lifeforms, and that one day ubiquitous and & Recommendations). Berlin: German Ethics
invasive data gathering will make human beings Council; 2017.
easy targets for “hacks” that end up constraining
their freedom as well as establishing and sustaining [6] Mueller M. Will the Internet Fragment?:
new power structures. From the perspective of the Sovereignty, Globalization and Cyberspace.
normative reference point of data sovereignty, is it Cambridge: Polity Press; 2017.
necessary to draw such dystopian conclusions?
Given the argument within this paper, there is no [7] Irion K. Government Cloud Computing and
question that Harari’s poignantly articulated National Data Sovereignty. Policy & Internet
diagnoses and challenges will be amongst the 2013;4:40–71.
central concerns of discourses on the responsible
development of technological innovations for many [8] Peterson ZNJ, Gondree M, Beverly R. A
more years to come. But regarding the prognostic Position Paper on Data Sovereignty: The
aspect of Harari’s vision, the normative reference Importance of Geolocating Data in the Cloud.
point of data sovereignty could be a promising first Proceedings of the 3rd USENIX Conference on
step towards navigating the possibilities of ICT in a Hot Topics in Cloud Computing, Berkeley, CA,
responsible, forward-looking, and hopeful manner. USA: USENIX Association; 2011.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT [9] De Filippi P, McCarthy S. Cloud Computing:
Centralization and Data Sovereignty.
We are grateful for funding from the German European Journal of Law and Technology
Federal Ministry of Health (ZMV/1 – 2517 FSB 013). 2012;3.

REFERENCES [10] Dabrock P. Die Würde des Menschen ist
granularisierbar. Muss die Grundlage unseres
[1] Harari YN. Will the Future be Human? Davos: Gemeinwesens neu gedacht werden? Epd-
World Economic Forum 2018. Dokumentation 2018;22/18:8–16.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_cont
inue=202&v=hL9uk4hKyg4. [11] Floridi L. The Fourth Revolution: How the
Infosphere is Reshaping Human Reality.
[2] Friedrichsen M, Bisa P-J. Digitale Souveränität: Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2014.
Vertrauen in der Netzwerkgesellschaft.
Wiesbaden: Springer VS; 2016. [12] Hummel P, Braun M, Dabrock P. Data
Donations As Exercises Of Sovereignty. In:
[3] De Mooy M. Rethinking Privacy Self- Krutzinna J, Floridi L, editors. The Ethics Of
Management and Data Sovereignty in the Age Medical Data Donation, Cham: Springer;
of Big Data: Considerations for Future Policy forthcoming.
Regimes in the United States and the
European Union. Bertelsmann Stiftung; 2017. [13] Westin AF. Privacy and Freedom. New York:
Atheneum; 1967.
[4] German Ethics Council. Big Data und
Gesundheit. Datensouveränität als [14] Solove DJ. Understanding Privacy. Cambridge,
informationelle Freiheitsgestaltung. Berlin: Massachusetts: Harvard University Press;
German Ethics Council; 2017. 2008.

[15] U.S. Department of Health, Education &
Welfare. Records, Computers, and the Rights
of Citizens. Report of the Secretary’s Advisory
Committee on Automated Personal Data
Systems. 1973.

90 © International Telecommunication Union, 2018