| Document 1(Rev.2)-E |
This document presents the draft strategic plan for the Union
1999-2003, prepared according to the instructions given in Council
Decision 476.
Pekka TARJANNE
Secretary-General
Page
Page
1. The purposes of the Union are set out in Article 1 of the Constitution (Geneva, 1992). Essentially, they are to provide a forum in which the Union's membership can cooperate for the improvement and rational use of telecommunications of all kinds in the following domains:
1.1 a technical domain - to promote the development, efficient operation, usefulness and general availability of telecommunication facilities and services;
1.2 a development domain - to promote the development of telecommunications in developing countries and the extension of the benefits of telecommunications to people everywhere;
1.3 a policy domain - to promote the adoption of a broader approach to telecommunication issues in the global information economy and society.
2. The objective of the strategic plan for the Union for 1999-2003 is to indicate how these purposes will be achieved in this period of time by identifying key issues, goals, strategies and priorities for the Union as a whole, for each of the Sectors, and for the secretariat.
3. The ITU strategic plan for 1995-1999 was based on an ambitious goal - to establish the Union as the international focal point for all matters relating to telecommunications in the global information economy and society. This goal was to be achieved through the following overall strategies:
3.1 to strengthen the foundations of the Union - by enhancing the participation of Sector Members and increasing synergy between the activities of the Sectors;
3.2 to broaden the Union's activities - by creating the World Telecommunication Policy Forum and using ITU resources and information systems more effectively;
3.3 to increase the Union's leverage in international affairs - by establishing strategic alliances with other concerned international and regional organizations, and communicating more effectively with the public.
4. The report of the Council to PP-98 on the activities of the Union since PP-94 provides a detailed assessment of the results of the 1995-99 strategic plan. Each of these strategies has been successful, to a greater or lesser degree. However, the overall goal as referred to in § 3 above has not been entirely realized, largely because of developments outside the control of the Union and its membership.
5. The telecommunication environment has evolved in ways that were not completely foreseen when the 1995-1999 strategic plan was being crafted. In particular, the forces of liberalization, competition and globalization have been stronger than anticipated. They have resulted in a shift in the way telecommunications is viewed - by policymakers and regulators, by customers, and by the industry itself. These forces will be further strengthened by the implementation in 1998 of agreements liberalizing trade in telecommunications at the international and regional levels.
6. In this new environment, it is no longer realistic to believe that the Union can be the focal point for all matters relating to telecommunications in the global information economy and society. The world is now too complex and telecommunications too pervasive for a single organization to be the focus of all issues of concern to the international community. New goals must be set and new strategies devised. That is the purpose of this document, which is organized as follows:
6.1 Part II identifies key trends and developments in the telecommunication environment and assesses their implications for ITU;
6.2 Part III proposes general strategic orientations, goals and priorities for achieving the purposes of the Union in the new environment in the 1999-2003 timeframe;
6.3 Part IV presents goals, strategies and priorities for the Sectors;
6.4 Part V proposes goals, strategies and priorities for the ITU secretariat.
7. The financial plan for the Union for 2000-2003 estimates the cost of ITU activities, identifies revenue options and establishes expenditure priorities on the basis of the provisions of the draft strategic plan.
8. The global market for telecommunications is expanding rapidly. It is not a question of "demand pull" or "supply push". Both are happening. The interaction of these two forces has made telecommunications one of the leading growth sectors in the world economy. It has also made telecommunications one of the most important components of social, cultural and political activity.
8.1 On the demand side, growth is pulled by an increasing reliance on telecommunications and information technology in every area of human life - in all sectors of economic and social activity; in government, in the provision of public services, and in the management of public infrastructures; in the pursuit of knowledge and the expression of culture; in the control of the environment; and in response to emergencies, whether natural or man-made.
8.2 On the supply side, growth is pushed by rapid technological developments which continuously improve the efficiency of existing products, systems and services, and provide the foundation for a continuing stream of innovations in each of these areas. Particularly noteworthy is the convergence of telecommunication, information, broadcasting and publishing technologies, which has greatly enriched the communication choices available to consumers.
9. The effect of the fundamental forces driving demand and supply has been amplified by the worldwide trend to liberalize markets for telecommunication and information technology goods and services. As a result of this trend, the majority of telecommunication networks are now privately owned and operated. Significant developments have also taken place to introduce competition at the national, regional and international levels. Of particular importance is the World Trade Organization (WTO) agreement to liberalize trade in basic telecommunication services which was concluded in February 1997 by 69 countries which together account for more than 90% of global telecommunication revenues. The agreement entered into force on 5 February 1998.
10. The new framework developed by WTO to govern trade and regulation of telecommunication services will facilitate further globalization of the telecommunication equipment and services industries, as well as the closely-related information technology industry.
10.1 In the 1995-1999 planning period, "globalization" was more a slogan than a reality, since it referred mainly to alliances between major operators to provide end-to-end services to multinational enterprises. Public networks and residential customers were relatively unaffected by this kind of globalization, although various forms of "alternative calling procedures" provided consumers in countries which allowed such practices a "poor-man's version" of the benefits enjoyed by big business users.
10.2 In the 1999-2003 planning period, globalization is likely to become much more of a reality. The WTO agreement will make it possible for foreign operators to have direct access through interconnection and interoperability to public networks in most of the world's major telecommunication markets, as well as to make direct investments in the development of those networks.
11. Five years ago, few would have predicted that the Internet would emerge so rapidly as a serious competitive force in telecommunications. However, today's Internet is only a precursor to the new competitive forces that are likely to emerge in the next 5 to 10 years in the new "communications and information sector" which will result from technological convergence.
12. The essential lesson to be learned from the Internet phenomenon is that competition is no longer a public policy tool which can be introduced in a completely controlled fashion and regulated within the confines of the traditional telecommunication sector. Competition in telecommunications is rapidly becoming a true market force whose evolution cannot be planned by policy-makers, a force which increasingly is seen as best regulated on the basis of principles that are not specific to telecommunications, but derived from a broader economic, social and cultural perspective.
13. Although far from universally accepted, the sweeping changes in telecommunications described above have broad support among many countries, including a number of developing countries who see it as the best way forward in developing their telecommunication networks and services to the benefit of their overall economic and social development.
14. The liberalization of telecommunications does not mean an end to regulation - but it has changed both the role of government and the nature of telecommunication regulation:
14.1 In the past, most ITU administrations tended to be "all-purpose" creatures - policy-makers and operators which both provided and regulated telecommunications on the basis of a "public utility" model.
14.2 The liberalization of telecommunications has been accompanied by a separation of these functions. The trend now is for ITU administrations to be policy-makers, nested within a general department of government (e.g. industry and trade); for telecommunications to be operated by corporations - whether public, private or mixed; and for "the public interest" in telecommunications to be protected by an independent regulatory authority.
14.3 In countries that have introduced partial or full competition, the model for regulating telecommunications is changing. Principles derived from competition law are taking their place alongside the classical precepts of public utility regulation. In some jurisdictions, sector-specific telecommunication regulation has been abandoned.
14.4 Again, the WTO agreement will amplify these regulatory trends. More than 60 signatories accounting for more than 90% of global telecommunication revenues have made commitments to apply in whole or in part a set of regulatory principles including interconnection, transparency and anti-competitive safeguards. These regulatory commitments, and indeed all other commitments, are subject to the WTO dispute resolution mechanism. They are therefore more than a voluntary code of conduct. They are binding commitments which are enforceable under the WTO dispute resolution mechanism.
15. In the 1999-2003 planning period, it is likely that the trends noted above with respect to liberalization, competition and globalization will begin to combine in new ways that may ultimately change the way the telecommunication industry sees itself and is seen by its regulator(s) and customers.
15.1 Countries that began permitting competition in telecommunications 10 or 20 years ago generally introduced it in a planned and orderly manner: first in terminal equipment; then in value-added services; then in the long-distance service; and finally in local and international services. In addition, competition was generally permitted among different service providers using the same infrastructure before being allowed between different infrastructure providers. Even today, most countries that permit competition do so on a highly regulated basis.
15.2 In this environment the regulator must implement competitive safeguards, nurture competition, ensure interconnection/interoperability and ensure broad and affordable access to necessary services.
15.3 As a result of technological progress, convergence and market liberalization, countries only now beginning to introduce competition are less likely to be in a position to plan an evolution of this kind.
15.4 Even in those countries that have experience with competition, service providers and regulators which have based their respective plans on an orderly evolution of this kind are finding that the "rules of the game" are suddenly changing, that competition is coming from unforeseen directions, and that it cannot be regulated as it was in the past.
15.5 More than any other phenomenon, the Internet symbolizes the changing nature of telecommunications. It is based on different technologies, network architectures, standardization and addressing schemes. Its economic foundations and charging principles are diametrically opposed to those of public telecommunication operators. It has experienced phenomenal growth and it has largely been outside government regulation. Yet it is emerging as a serious alternative to the traditional services provided by the telecommunication industry in every market segment from intra-corporate communications to public voice.
16. From one point of view, encouraging progress has been made in the 1995-1999 period in certain countries and some regions in forging the "missing link" identified by the Maitland Commission. Overall, the gap between developed and developing countries in access to basic telecommunication services is closing. However, from other points of view, new gaps are beginning to appear:
16.1 In general, the majority of the least developed countries (LDCs) have made little progress in the past five years in closing the gap in access to basic telecommunication services. In some cases, teledensity (the number of telephone lines per 100 people) has fallen, as population growth has outstripped telecommunication growth. New technologies such as global mobile personal communications by satellite (GMPCS) may help close the "telecommunication gap". This will only be possible, however, if their services are affordable to inhabitants of the LDCs.
16.2 There is currently an enormous gap between developed and developing countries in access to the Internet. Even as the telecommunication gap which has preoccupied the Union for so many years is beginning to close, an "information gap" of even greater proportions is opening up.
16.3 A difference in regulatory practices is emerging between countries which have decided to liberalize their telecommunication markets under the WTO agreements, and those that have not. If competition brings the first group of countries the anticipated benefits in terms of investment, technology transfer, innovative services and lower prices, these regulatory differences may become a new development gap. In this regard, it is important to recall that although the 119 ITU Member States that are not yet part of the WTO basic telecommunications agreement generate less than 10% of global telecommunication revenues, they include more than 90% of the world's people.
17. On the eve of the 21st century, the Union thus finds itself in a dynamic situation. On the one hand, the goal established by the Maitland Commission of achieving universal access to basic telecommunications will be technically achieved, and the overall gap between developed and developing countries is steadily narrowing. However, at the same time, new differences are developing, for example within the developing world, between the LDCs and other developing countries, between liberalized and non-liberalized countries which may be either developed or developing, and between countries that are moving rapidly towards competition and those moving at a slower pace.
18. This raises important questions in relation to the vision of the global information society (GIS). This vision was the subject of considerable discussion during the 1995-1999 period, initially in the G-7 group of advanced industrial economies, then in the broader international community. Today, the basic ideas behind the concept of the GIS have been broadly accepted and indeed endorsed. In this vision, all forms of economic, social, cultural and political activity will increasingly depend on access to the telecommunication and information services provided by the global information infrastructure (GII). The rapid development of electronic commerce on the Internet is one tangible example of how the GIS is becoming a reality. The challenge facing the international community is to find ways to ensure that the GIS is truly global, and that people everywhere are able to share in its benefits.
19. As a result of these trends and developments, demand for the products and services provided by ITU has risen in the 1995-1999 period and is expected to continue to rise in the 1999-2003 time-frame. This is the case for the services provided to the ITU membership (e.g. meetings, recommendations, assistance in applying regulations, frequency and number registrations, technical and development assistance) as well as those provided to the international telecommunication community as a whole (e.g. exhibitions, forums, development indicators, trend reports, information services).
20. One of the most important strategic issues facing the Union in the 1999-2003 period is how to respond to these rising demands:
20.1 The ITU functions within the framework of the United Nations common system. Since the ITU budget has been based on "zero growth" for a number of years, it has only been possible to respond to increased demand for products and services through productivity improvements. Further improvements can and will continue to be made.
20.2 The 19951999 strategic plan noted that assessed contributions from Member States had "reached a plateau; income from these sources appears unlikely to grow dramatically and may begin to decline". Four years later, it is clear that this was an accurate assessment. This is the financial reality the membership faces in preparing a strategic and financial plan for 1999-2003.
20.3 While unquestioned, the intergovernmental nature of ITU is acknowledged by Member States and Sector Members alike as placing certain limits on enhancing Sector Members' rights and obligations. It does limit the role of Sector Members in decision-making, and although Sector Member rights have been somewhat enhanced, the intergovernmental nature of ITU might limit Sector Members' willingness to make increased financial contributions which they cannot control. Implementation of recommendations deriving from Resolution 15 (Kyoto, 1994) and Resolution 39 (Kyoto, 1994) can lessen these constraints and facilitate cooperation between Member States and Sector Members.
20.4 The solution to strengthening the Union lies in treating the Sector Members more as partners in appropriate work of the Union. The Union will have to see itself as seeking to satisfy the needs of its customers by providing products and services of superior value in a competitive environment. Many Sector Members have had to transform their organizational cultures in this fashion, and it is natural that they will expect to see similar changes in the Union.
20.5 Another factor affecting the future effectiveness of the Union is the process of decision-making. Even as ITU has supported some improvements during 1995-1999, including the use of web technology, advanced electronic communication and document exchange facilities, the number of ITU meetings, meeting days, participants and pages of documents produced per meeting has continued to grow. That the membership has turned to ITU to satisfy their diverse needs should be seen as an indication of the value that can be provided by the Union. Therefore, appropriate changes in the working methods are required, along with financial responsibility based on a transparent budget process and generally accepted accounting principles.
21. There are clearly major challenges facing the Union as it seeks to respond to rising demand for its products and services. However, each of these challenges has a positive side which provides an opportunity to build on ITU's "core competencies":
21.1 The Union is an acknowledged leader in the movement to reform international organizations by enhancing the participation of non-government players, increasing efficiency, and adopting innovative approaches to achieving its purposes.
21.2 The Union has a comprehensive membership and "high approval rating" among the members of the international telecommunication community. The vast majority of the Union's Member States freely choose to contribute more than they would if they were assessed under some measure such as GDP or teledensity. And during the 1995-1999 period, Sector membership almost doubled as new players on the international telecommunication scene and companies from convergent industries were added to the ranks of established players.
21.3 Member States, Sector Members and the international community have shown a continuing willingness to pay for many ITU products and services. Demand has remained strong for established publications and TELECOM events. In addition, customers have responded well to the innovative range of ITU information products and services which have been introduced in the past four years.
21.4 In every major test of its decision-making ability in the 1995-1999 period, the Union has been able to respond with activities that have led to beneficial results for all concerned.
22. The strategic challenge facing the Union in the 1999-2003 time-frame is to remain a pre-eminent international forum where Member States and Sector Members work together to enable the development of telecommunication networks and to facilitate universal access to communication and information services, so that people everywhere can participate in and benefit from the global information economy and society.
23. The purposes of the Union are achieved through the activities of its three Sectors, through the Sector conferences and assemblies, and through general-purpose activities such as the Plenipotentiary Conference, the World Conference on International Telecommunications and the Council, as well as the World Telecommunication Policy Forum and TELECOM exhibitions and forums.
24. The ITU is a federal organization. Although financial resources are centrally controlled, each Sector has its own "governance structure" which defines the goals, strategies and activities necessary to achieve its mission in a given period of time. However, just as the purposes of the Union set out in Article 1 of the Constitution apply to all Sectors, so they share a number of strategic orientations and goals.
25. "Strategic orientations" are principles intended to provide coherence, focus and direction to all of the activities undertaken by the Union. It is impossible to forecast the future completely in the rapidly changing telecommunication environment and to plan for every contingency. Strategic orientations therefore help to ensure consistency of purpose and action in the face of inevitable uncertainty.
26. The following strategic orientations are proposed for the 1999-2003 strategic plan. They build on the experience of the 1995-1999 period, particularly the results of implementation of Resolution 15 (Kyoto, 1994) and Resolution 39 (Kyoto, 1994), and they seek to apply that experience to the anticipated requirements of the new environment analysed in part II of this document, in addition to encouraging development of access to basic telecommunication and information services:
26.1 improve customer service - by identifying the specific needs of the Union's membership and other customers, establishing priorities, and providing the highest quality of service possible with available resources;
26.2 innovate - by continuing to develop new activities, products and services under the supervision of the Member States and Sector Members and in accordance with their agreed needs;
26.3 strengthen the Union's financial foundations - by determining and applying appropriate funding mechanisms for ITU activities, products and services (e.g. assessed contribution based on free choice of contributory unit, voluntary contribution, partial or full cost recovery, revenue generation), together with transparent budgetary measures;
26.4 enhance participation by Sector Members - by implementing the recommendations deriving from Resolution 15 (Kyoto, 1994) and Resolution 39 (Kyoto, 1994) as quickly and fully as possible, and by actively marketing ITU membership to all entities and organizations with a potential interest in participating actively in the work of the Union;
26.5 establish partnerships - by concluding a range of formal and informal cooperation agreements with other intergovernmental organizations and with other organizations at the national and regional levels, including non-governmental organizations (NGOs), in cases where such cooperation would further the purposes of the Union based upon the identification of specific subjects for cooperation;
26.6 maintain solidarity - between the ITU's Member States and Sector Members in partnership in pursuit of the purposes of the Union;
26.7 inform - by sharing and disseminating information related to the development of economically efficient public telecommunications;
26.8 promote the principle and implementation of a competitive telecommunication environment - by encouraging flexible regulatory systems that provide for a variety of telecommunication services;
26.9 produce Recommendations in timely response to market demand - by streamlining development and approval procedures by each Sector, as appropriate.
27. In addition to these strategic orientations, the Sectors of the Union share a number of goals for the 1999-2003 period, and will undertake priority actions to achieve these goals.
28. The trends and developments analysed in part II of this document illustrate the multilateral nature of key ITU activities. Since the most basic purpose of the Union is to maintain and extend international cooperation between all its members for the improvement and rational use of telecommunications, the central goal of the Union's strategy must be to take this into account and strengthen multilateral cooperation in areas where its effectiveness may be in question. To this end, the following priority actions are proposed:
28.1 ITU-R
Considering the implications of the large increase in workload for preparation of, participation in and follow-up work of WRCs, and taking appropriate action;
Further enhancing the structure of ITU-R through clarification of the roles of the RAG, RA and WRC, and in particular establishing clearer linkages between advisory, decision-making and budgetary responsibilities.
28.2 ITU-T
Producing high-quality Recommendations quickly in response to market demands;
Broadening participation and enhancing involvement by non-administration entities in the Sector's standardization process;
Developing Recommendations to achieve accounting rate reform and proposing means to encourage their implementation.
28.3 ITU-D
Developing new approaches to the provision of multilateral telecommunication assistance, inter alia by building partnerships for telecommunication development in priority areas, with special emphasis on telecommunication sector restructuring, regulatory reform, finance and resource mobilization, technology applications and human resource development.
28.4 General activities
Developing the World Telecommunication Policy Forum (WTPF) as a forum convened on an ad hoc basis for developing a nonbinding shared vision on cross-Sectoral policy issues;
Where agreed by the membership, developing innovative mechanisms for international cooperation outside the formal structures defined in the Constitution and Convention (e.g. MoUs);
Deciding on the need to revise the International Telecommunication Regulations (ITR) to take account of developments in the telecommunication environment, particularly the WTO agreements;
Extending cooperative participation to an increasing number of administrations and organizations, by encouraging the participation of Member States not currently active in ITU activities, encouraging and facilitating the participation of additional entities and organizations, including small or narrowlyfocused entities, and increasing coordination and cooperation with other relevant international and regional organizations.
29. The vision of the GIS will become a reality only if the networks and services of the converging telecommunication and information industries are able to interconnect and interwork seamlessly, and if they are accessible to people everywhere at affordable rates. Facilitating development of the GII and promoting universal access to basic telecommunication and information services is a goal that unites all ITU Sectors. Priority actions proposed for 1999-2003 include:
29.1 ITU-R
Accommodating the global and regional spectrum requirements of innovative telecommunication and information services.
29.2 ITU-T
Developing Recommendations for new technologies and applications such as appropriate aspects of the GII and global multimedia and mobility.
29.3 ITU-D
Promoting the development, expansion and operation of telecommunication networks and services, particularly in developing countries, taking into account the activities of other relevant bodies, with universal access as the objective;
Developing and/or sponsoring projects designed to connect developing countries to the GII (e.g. Africa ONE, Internet access);
Promoting the development of technology applications (e.g. tele-health, teleeducation, electronic commerce, environmental protection, disaster relief) in cooperation with other international and regional organizations and NGOs.
29.4 General activities
Connecting ITU Member States, Sector Members and other members of the international telecommunity to the Union's information resources and to each other through an "ITU-II" (ITU information infrastructure), to help them develop the GII in their own areas of responsibility;
Pursuing implementation of the United Nations system-wide project on universal access to basic communication and information services - the "right to communicate";
Facilitate access to telecommunications through the promotion of cost effective technologies and low price services to end users, that comply with standards and quality requirements.
30. Although we are living in an era of technological abundance, some communication resources remain scarce. The coordination of international action to manage resources such as the radiofrequency spectrum, satellite orbital positions and telecommunication numbers is a wellestablished and core role of ITU. In addition, human resources and information are becoming recognized as scarce resources of a different kind that are critical to developing countries in the new environment. The following priority actions are therefore proposed for 1999-2003:
30.1 ITU-R
Improving the frequency coordination and planning framework for satellite networks.
30.2 ITU-T
Developing and implementing administrative procedures for numbering plans for international networks and services.
30.3 ITU-D
Contributing to and coordinating actions between Member States and Sector Members aimed at developing human resources, especially in the associated regulatory and economic domains.
30.4 General activities
Serving as the depository of cooperative international arrangements consistent with the purposes of ITU.
31. As indicated in part II, the current telecommunication environment is a dynamic one, characterized by rapid technological progress but also by emerging differences, for example within the developing countries, between liberalized and nonliberalized countries, and between countries that are moving more rapidly towards competition and those moving at a slower pace. Countries will be assisted in adapting to this environment if they have available good information not only on the global environment but also on the issues and options they face. Each ITU Sector, and ITU as a whole, has a role to play in providing this information. The following priority actions are therefore proposed for 1999-2003:
31.1 ITU-R
Providing assistance to all Member States, and especially the developing countries, through the dissemination of information and know-how, in particular on spectrum management.
31.2 ITU-T
Producing Recommendations responding to technological developments, in accordance with the priorities shown in § 41 below;
Working with BDT with special attention to telecommunication development in developing countries, and cooperating with the other Sectors in the organization of information meetings, seminars and workshops, and in the development of case studies, guidelines and handbooks.
31.3 ITU-D
Continuing to develop the telecommunication indicators and regulatory databases, and to add value to the information they contain through partnerships with other Sectors and organizations;
Assisting developing countries in addressing policy and regulatory issues arising from the liberalization, convergence and globalization of telecommunications, while taking account of the GATS principles inherent in the WTO basic telecommunication agreement and Reference Paper (e.g. through studies, workshops, missions and cooperative mechanisms);
Providing information about mechanisms for financing telecommunication development and assisting developing countries with the mobilization of resources for telecommunication investment;
Disseminating information about ITU-R and ITU-T activities that are of particular importance for developing countries.
31.4 General activities
Providing opportunities for the sharing of information and experience regarding relevant issues, such as convergence, globalization, regulatory principles and universal service, and regarding benefits to the public interest, investors and the national economy;
Assisting countries most in need to draw maximum benefit from technical, financial and regulatory changes in the telecommunication environment.
32 To remain a pre-eminent international and market-relevant focal point for matters related to the rapidly changing telecommunication environment, ITU must regularly review and, as appropriate, update its structure, activities and processes, ensuring that they are effective and efficient in the light of the current needs of its membership. To this end, the following items are proposed for 1999-2003:
32.1 ITU-R
Fostering the cost effective processing of information received from administrations in the application of the provisions of the Radio Regulations, the orderly recording and registration of frequency assignments and orbital positions and the development of Recommendations, handbooks and other relevant outputs in a rapidly changing environment, while continuing to evaluate Sector structure, activities and processes with a view to remaining effective and efficient.
32.2 ITU-T
Continuing to improve the working methods of the Sector, including the accelerated development of Recommendations, the fostering of cooperative relationships with other relevant standardization organizations and the increased use both of EDH and project teams (see § 41 below);
Assisting in developing, for the Telecommunication Standardization Sector, an open and transparent "bottom up" budget proposal that incorporates financial management principles and techniques, including cost recovery as appropriate.
32.3 ITU-D
Strengthening BDT's advisory capabilities through redistribution of its resources, to respond to requests in priority areas such as international agreements and national regulation, tariffs and finance, new and convergent technologies and the feasibility stage of negotiations;
Developing its catalytic role in encouraging all actors, including
global, regional and national organizations, to work together
in assisting developing countries in
their development and reform process as well as in their adaptation
to the liberalized market;
Strengthening regional presence by increasing the decentralization of functions and authority to field offices and by strengthening the coordination functions of headquarters.3
32.4 General activities
Increasing the use of modern methods of telecommunication, including electronic handling of submissions to ITU such as frequency and orbit notifications/registrations, and providing information to its customers;
Streamlining the development, approval and publication processes for Recommendations in each Sector, as appropriate;
Increasing the use of task-oriented activities using the working methods agreed to in each Sector, such as rapporteur, focus and correspondence groups, while ensuring transparency;
Developing a clear, transparent budget, encouraging each Sector and the General Secretariat to develop "bottom up" budgets, and working to implement cost recovery, as appropriate;
Improving the financial accountability of activities within ITU by more clearly linking costs with the related activity through annual Sector operational and financial plans consistent with the biennial budget.
33. Under the provisions of the Constitution and Convention (Geneva, 1992), the mission of the ITU Radiocommunication Sector is, inter alia, to ensure rational, equitable, efficient and economical use of the radio-frequency spectrum by all radiocommunication services, including those using satellite orbits, and to carry out studies and adopt Recommendations on radiocommunication matters.
34. This mission is to be undertaken in an environment that is characterized by:
Growing recognition of the economic value of frequency spectrum and the application of economic principles in the management of that resource, recognizing the rapid market-driven and user-oriented technological development;
The ever increasing demand for the limited radio-frequency spectrum for space and terrestrial radiocommunication systems;
The growing role of regional organizations and private-sector activities in a deregulated environment;
The limited financial resources available to support the Sector's activities;
Growing convergence among many radio services, integration with wired telecommunication services and converging terrestrial and satellite applications;
Increased interest, in particular on the part of the developing countries, in:
- access to the radiocommunication spectrum and the geostationary-satellite orbit in support of their national requirements;
- worldwide radiocommunication system standards to achieve overall system economy;
- handbooks;
the rapid technological development and widespread application of digital techniques to most space and terrestrial systems, including mobile communications and new television and sound broadcasting systems.
35. Within its overall mission, the strategic objectives of ITU-R are to carry out the functions laid down in the Constitution and Convention, and specifically, in the period 1999-2003:
to maintain and enhance the relevance of ITU-R in the efficient management of the usable radio-frequency spectrum, free from harmful interference, and to ensure that the Radio Regulations and the rights of Member States are respected;
to continue developing enhanced criteria for frequency sharing and coordination of new and existing systems in both space and terrestrial environments, with a view to increasing the efficiency of use of the usable frequency spectrum;
to continue improving the working methods and cost-effective operation of ITU-R in a flexible organizational structure; to aim at more efficient and more clearly defined roles of the RAG, radiocommunication assemblies and radiocommunication conferences to ensure clear linkages between advisory, decision-making and budgetary responsibilities as new and more efficient working methods evolve; and to further develop the Sector's quality of service and enhance its use of electronic document handling;
to ensure that the Radio Regulations Board carries out its functions, particularly those concerning the application of the Radio Regulations, in a manner which maintains the confidence of Member States;
to undertake, in project teams, the study of approved Questions limited in scope and time, as appropriate; and urgent studies decided by WRCs, in preparation for future WRCs;
in close collaboration with ITU-D and ITUT, as appropriate, to assist developing countries in spectrum management and disseminate information and know-how through information meetings, seminars, handbooks and the provision of tools for automated spectrum management;
to provide information on widely accepted spectrum management concepts and related regulatory frameworks, particularly with a view to assisting developing countries, and to assist in the application of relevant ITU-R Recommendations providing guidance on the most economical and timely implementation of radiocommunication systems;
to issue Recommendations on, inter alia, the characteristics and performance of radio systems;
to implement efficient measures to promote broader participation by Member States, particularly developing countries, and Sector Members in all ITU-R activities.
36. The priorities of the Radiocommunication Sector for 1999-2003, in addition to those that may be identified by future conferences, are:
to review the world radiocommunication conference process to ensure that it is effective and efficient, that the agendas developed do not unduly burden Member States and Sector Members and consequently burden Secretariat resources, and that the intervals between conferences are appropriate;
to accommodate the global and regional spectrum requirements of innovative services that will provide communication and information services "any time, any place" (e.g. GMPCS, IMT2000 and high altitude platform stations, all of which include innovative terrestrial and space applications), by the appropriate consideration of such matters at WRCs and by issuing appropriate Recommendations to facilitate their development and implementation;
to study and apply, as appropriate, improved international spectrum management techniques;
to facilitate timely coordination between new and existing active and passive systems in both space and terrestrial environments and to develop spectrum regulation initiatives to better harmonize frequency allocations and the use of satellite orbits, while continuing work to improve the frequency coordination and planning process for satellite networks;
to expand the assistance offered to Member States in coordinating and registering frequency assignments and in applying the Radio Regulations, with special attention to developing countries and Member States that have recently joined the Union;
to collaborate as needed with ITU-T and ITU-D and the General Secretariat to ensure that studies are appropriately coordinated and that no duplication of work occurs;
to provide assistance to the Telecommunication Development Bureau (BDT) for the introduction of modern radio systems in developing countries, particularly in rural areas, conduct information meetings and world and regional seminars and give assistance to Member States, with special attention to developing countries, e.g. through the development of handbooks;
in improving the working methods of the Sector, to strive for:
- greater use of user-friendly document exchange capabilities;
- the accelerated development of Recommendations and improvement in publication mechanisms (reduction of unit cost and time taken to publish, wider distribution and greater electronic availability);
- increased use of information technology for the notification and processing of frequency assignments;
- a flexible organizational structure in the Radiocommunication Bureau (BR) with special attention to the training and development of the Bureau's staff;
- periodic study group reviews of work programmes to re-establish priorities and improve effectiveness;
to encourage greater participation by Member States, Sector Members and other organizations in ITU-R activities, inter alia by concluding formal and informal taskoriented cooperation arrangements.
37. Under the provisions of the Constitution and Convention (Geneva, 1992), the mission of the ITU Telecommunication Standardization Sector is to fulfil the purposes of the Union relating to telecommunication standardization by studying technical, operating and tariff questions and adopting Recommendations on them with a view to standardizing telecommunications on a worldwide basis.
38. Taking account of rapid change in the telecommunication environment, the mission of the Telecommunication Standardization Sector for the period of 1999-2003 will include:
maintaining and strengthening its pre-eminence in international telecommunication standardization by developing Recommendations rapidly, for example through increased Sector Member participation and use in appropriate cases of a faster alternative approval process;
developing Recommendations that acknowledge market- and trade-related considerations;
playing a leading role in the promotion of cooperation among international and regional standardization organizations and forums and consortia concerned with telecommunications;
addressing important issues related to changes due to competition, tariff principles and accounting practices; and
developing Recommendations for new technologies and applications such as appropriate aspects of the GII and global multimedia and mobility.
39. The mission is to be undertaken in an environment characterized by:
rapid technological change and shortened innovation cycles, development and convergence of telecommunication, broadcasting, computer and information technology, and growth of new products and services;
a worldwide trend towards a "market-driven" approach to standardization, with an emphasis on rapid implementation of high quality Recommendations;
an era of explosive growth in worldwide information transfer;
the changing role of governments, and the increased involvement of Sector Members, in the standardization process;
the strong influence of relevant regional standardization organizations and forums and consortia;
an increased number of network operators and service providers due to deregulation and/or privatization;
increasing privatization and heightened competition between and among network operators, service providers and equipment suppliers;
increasing number of global telecommunication operators, systems and alliances;
greatly increasing demand of developing countries for infrastructure development;
potential changes to the financial resources available to support Sector activities.
40. The overall mission of the Telecommunication Standardization Sector can be realized by targeting the following strategic objectives in ITU-T activities:
to produce high-quality Recommendations quickly in response to market demands;
to broaden participation and enhance involvement by non-administration entities in the Sector's standardization process;
to enhance Sector Member participation in the standardization process, including their involvement in appropriate decision-making;
to continue to improve the working methods of ITU-T, including the improved and accelerated development and approval of Recommendations;
to develop appropriate arrangements and cooperative relationships with regional and national standardization organizations and forums and consortia;
to respond to the impacts of increased privatization and competition in network operation and service provision, and to the reforms in the accounting rate system;
to encourage the participation of developing countries in telecommunication standardization activities;
to encourage cooperation with the Telecommunication Development Sector through timely responses to relevant requests;
to actively involve TSAG in financial aspects of the Telecommunication Standardization Sector.
41. The priorities of the Telecommunication Standardization Sector for 1999-2003, in addition to those that may be identified by future conferences, are:
to produce Recommendations responding to technological developments, including Recommendations:
* covering the implementation of the GII, including the definition of an integrated global framework reference model with network-network and network-user interfaces;
* covering the multimedia applications arising from the convergence of telecommunication, broadcasting, computer and information technology;
* covering the further evolution of network infrastructures, for example in the areas of network access, signalling and control, interfaces, security and optical networking;
* facilitating the interworking of global personal radiocommunication systems with public telecommunication networks;
* facilitating the integration of existing and new transmission media in public networks, in cooperation with ITU-R for radio transmission aspects;
to continue to improve the working methods of the Sector through the:
* accelerated development of Recommendations to keep pace with rapid technical progress and market demand;
* fostering of cooperative relationships with other relevant standardization organizations and with forums and consortia to avoid duplication of work, identify gaps in work programmes and encourage work sharing where possible;
* increased use of electronic document handling (EDH) techniques to increase efficiency and productivity;
* greater use of project teams for the study of urgent issues in a relatively short timeframe;
to develop Recommendations to achieve accounting rate reform and to propose means to encourage their implementation;
to work with BDT with special attention to telecommunication development in developing countries, and to cooperate with the other Sectors in the organization of information meetings, seminars and workshops and in the development of case studies, guidelines and handbooks;
to assist in developing for ITU-T an open and transparent "bottom up" budget proposal that incorporates financial management principles and techniques, including cost recovery as appropriate.
42. As noted in the Buenos Aires Declaration (1994) (additions highlighted in italics):
"Telecommunications is an essential component of political, economic, social and cultural development. It fuels the global information society and economy which is rapidly transforming local, national and international life and despite physical boundaries is promoting better understanding between peoples. Thus, ITU Members have the duty to provide for communications to be made available to all individuals, groups and peoples. A dynamic area of economic activity in its own right, telecommunications underlies practically all areas of economic activity and facilitates trade. New technological developments in telecommunication and information technologies such as the deployment of GMPCS and the Internet have the potential to close the development gaps between developing and developed countries and, in individual countries, between densely and sparsely populated areas. Also, telecommunications can play an important role in protecting the environment and in improving health care and education.
Telecommunications may however unintentionally perpetuate the development gaps without a more determined, integrated and strategic approach to the challenges of telecommunication development by governments, the private sector and international and regional organizations".
43. The mission of the Development Sector is set out in the Constitution and the Convention (Geneva, 1992). Article 21 of the Constitution states that:
44. Resolution 1 (Kyoto, 1994) describes the telecommunication development environment as follows (some new factors are added, highlighted in italics in the text):
restructuring and liberalization of the telecommunication sector at the national and international level, and the three agreements on basic telecommunications, on technology and on finance concluded through the World Trade Organization have increasing consequences for the provision of international and national telecommunication services. Competition is rapidly becoming the rule rather than the exception;
the above factors are straining the accounting-rate system beyond its limits, calling for a rapid revision of accounting rates and threatening traditional income flows that have been of critical importance to certain countries;
the gap between developed and developing countries has narrowed slightly in terms of access to basic telephone services, but has widened at a fast rate where advanced telecommunication services and access to information are concerned;
rapid development of telecommunications in some countries, associated with general economic growth;
modest and uneven progress in other countries, particularly in the Africa region, where economic growth has stagnated and telecommunications has not yet been extensively restructured, except in a few countries;
many different development actors including non-governmental organizations (NGOs) now play a greater role in telecommunication development;
information technology is revolutionizing the way business is done, including development activities (planning, training and so on);
the emergence of a global information society is rapidly creating a new imbalance in development between industrialized and developing countries. Political, technical, cultural and financial factors are combining to aggravate this imbalance;
the persistent decline in official development assistance flows over the past years, coupled with a reorientation of priorities (excluding the telecommunication sector) set by UNDP's Executive Board, the lack of priority given by recipient developing countries to the sector when seeking UNDP assistance and the introduction of new and alternative executing arrangements (which result in the exclusion of ITU) have had a negative effect on ITU-D project execution which has been only partially offset by a rise in funds-in-trust and voluntary contributions, thereby reducing the financial resources available to the Development Sector;
increasing emphasis on policy and regulatory frameworks which create open markets and encourage private investment (including foreign investment), with the result that development programmes rely less and less on technical assistance and more and more on partnerships and trade agreements;
private capital flows are now five times greater than official development aid resources;
the funds available to ITU for telecommunication development will remain limited when compared with the needs of developing countries, requiring ITU to play a catalytic role. The way this role is envisaged is developed further in the following section.
45. The following factors have to be taken into account when defining a strategy for the Development Sector, several of which were already noted in the Buenos Aires Declaration:
ITU strategic cooperation for the development of telecommunications must recognize the varying levels of development in developing countries. While the convergence between medium and high teledensity countries is encouraging, there is still a growing divergence between medium and low teledensity ones. This fact underscores the need to pay special attention to the requirements of the least developed countries. It also points out the need for well-differentiated and tailored responses for the various types of countries (developing countries, LDCs, transition economies, countries affected by conflicts or natural disasters, etc.)
Given that the telecommunication requirements of most developing countries are vast, and the resources available to meet them limited, ITU should work with governments to assist them in establishing appropriate telecommunication policies and regulatory structures
The development of telecommunications may be fostered by liberalization, private investment and competition in appropriate circumstances. Their introduction in any restructuring exercise should be compatible with national development goals and with improving service to underserved areas. Such a restructuring should include a regulatory system which will:
- create a stable and transparent environment to attract investment;
- facilitate access of service providers to the network with a framework that promotes fair competition while protecting network integrity;
- ensure the provision of universal service, promoting innovation and the introduction of new services and technologies to rural users; and
- guarantee the rights of users, operators and investors.
46. Restructuring should promote partnerships between telecommunication organizations in developing and developed countries that take equitable account of the interests of developing countries.
ITU has a special role to play in advising policy-makers on the options available in tailoring policies and regulatory structures to fit a country's particular requirements. The Union should work in close cooperation with regional telecommunication organizations and international, regional and national development and financing agencies. In the accelerating process of worldwide competitive struggle, market restructuring and the reduction of barriers to trade and finance affecting telecommunications, ITU is increasingly called upon by decision-makers of countries in need of support to assist them in:
Since the resources available through multilateral cooperation will not be sufficient to meet the requirements of developing countries, ITU must play a creative catalytic role in concert with all the entities forming part of its wide family and with global, regional and national organizations and agencies and the private sector.
The studies carried out in ITU-R and ITU-T play a significant role in the sharing of knowledge and know-how. Close cooperation between these Sectors and ITU-D is necessary in order to inject new dynamism in this process
Development strategies should encompass information technology and sound and television broadcasting via terrestrial and satellite systems as key factors in promoting economic, social and cultural development
No telecommunication network can be designed, installed and operated efficiently without appropriately skilled staff at all levels. Human resources development and management require innovative approaches to meet the challenges of the rapidly changing telecommunication environment.
47. In the five major areas of telecommunication development: telecommunication sector reform, technologies, management, finance and human resources, the ITU-D strategy will be based on four main modes of action:
a) Direct assistance, including project execution
b) Resource development and mobilization
c) Partnerships
d) Information sharing
48. During the period 1999-2003, priorities will continue shifting. While carrying out its functions in accordance with the Constitution and the Convention, the strategic priorities of the Development Sector for the period 1999-2003 are provisionally defined as follows, partially adding to the language used in Resolution 1 (Kyoto, 1994) and incorporating the operative part of several current resolutions:
49. ITU-D provides assistance to developing countries to strengthen, expand and harmonize their telecommunication networks and services by:
assisting countries to create the necessary policy, strategic and investment environment that will allow and enable the successful development of telecommunications, by mobilizing the support of key decision-makers in all sectors;
assisting the telecommunication sector to develop and strengthen its institutional, organizational and functional capacity;
assisting those who are involved in telecommunication development to acquire the necessary and appropriate knowledge and expertise in the latest developments in telecommunications.
responding effectively, rapidly and in a flexible way to requests for technical assistance by LDCs and countries in special need of assistance, as well as countries in transition and other developing countries, including through cost recovery as applicable;
maintaining and strengthening the Special Voluntary Programme for Technical Cooperation based on financial contributions, expert services or any other form of contribution to meet as many of the telecommunication requests of developing countries as possible;
continuing efforts to apply Resolution 36/68 of the United Nations General Assembly and other resolutions relevant to assistance to refugees in collaboration with the organizations concerned;
performing a catalytic role in initiating regional and subregional projects, particularly those that could serve as case studies or models for other developing countries.
50. ITU-D develops and mobilizes resources, including financial and human resources, technology, information and expertise for telecommunication development, through constant action to:
identify sources of financing and assist in mobilizing financial resources for telecommunication investments;
develop and disseminate human resources management tools and systems;
develop, manage and disseminate information databases of interest for the development process.
51. ITU-D plays a catalytic and facilitating role in encouraging all the actors in telecommunications to work together in telecommunication development. More specifically, it promotes and facilitates the active involvement of developed countries and the international community in the development process by:
engaging in strategic partnerships and extending services and cooperation to all Member States and Sector Members, with special emphasis on the least-developed countries, inter alia through pilot projects and technical cooperation projects aimed at sustainable telecommunication development;
working in collaboration with the other Sectors, the Member States and the Sector Members, the organizations of the United Nations family and the regional telecommunication organizations towards a global approach to telecommunication development and improved cooperation at the regional and global level;
establishing strategic alliances and cooperation arrangements with other concerned international and regional organizations: World Bank, WTO, UNESCO, WHO, UNEP, UNCTAD, etc. in order to act more selectively and focus on those areas where each organization has a comparative advantage;
encouraging the private sector to participate effectively in ITU-D activities;
supporting ITU-D action as well as the action of the other ITU Sectors through an effective regional presence geared to the specific requirements of each region;
continuing to participate fully in UNDP activities as a UNDP executing agency, as well as with other development agencies inside and outside the United Nations system and other arrangements such as funds-in-trust, cost sharing and TELECOM surplus funds;
continuing participation in the UNESCO International Programme for the Development of Communication, in the InfoDev programme of the World Bank and continuing the cooperation with WorldTel;
promoting the horizontal (transsectoral) dimension of telecommunications in the overall socioeconomic development process through application projects (telemedicine, teleeducation, environment protection, etc.) conducted cooperatively with other specialized organizations in their respective domains of competency.
52. A key role of ITU-D will be the collection, sharing and dissemination of information:
strengthening BDT competency in the field of information sharing in terms of research, documentation, information exchange and assistance in order to act as a clearing house on national laws, regulations, licensing and joint-venture arrangements, etc.;
extending and improving the collection and dissemination of information on the development of telecommunications worldwide, establishing a "global information system" with on-line access for the development partners and continuing to provide authoritative and up-to-date information through the World Telecommunication Development Report, development indicators, databases, country profiles, etc.;
continuing to promote the value of telecommunications for overall social and economic development through studies, publications, symposia, workshops and other forms of information dissemination, recognizing the role of telecommunications as a trade;
giving every possible encouragement for increasing the role played by telecommunication and information technologies in extending social services such as health care, education, environmental protection and sustainable development.
53. In support of its action to meet these operational priorities, ITU-D should continue to improve its structure and working methods with a view to serving its clients better in delivering higher-quality products and services.
54. Based on the resolutions and recommendations of the regional and world telecommunication development conferences (1995-1998), a successor to the Buenos Aires Action Plan may be adopted with more focus on its "seed" character, aiming at strengthening ITU-D's function as a catalyst in promoting and supporting partnerships to deliver timely development results. It would comprise four chapters:
Chapter 1: Programme of cooperation among the members of the Telecommunication Development Sector:
Chapter 2: the former 12 programmes of the BAAP are likely to be replaced by 6 programmes focusing on major requirements:
Programme 1: Sector reform, regulation and legislation;
Programme 2: Technologies and GII development and applications, including GMPCS and Internet;
Programme 3: Rural development and universal service;
Programme 4: Finance and economics, including WTO issues, tariffs, accounting rates, etc.
Programme 5: Development partnerships with the private sector;
Programme 6: Human resources development and management, with a focus on using computer-based training, teletraining, group training, etc.
Chapter 3: An LDC Action Plan comprising a set of activities (country programmes) for each of the 48 least developed countries, aiming at a real impact on their telecommunication development.
Chapter 4: Execution of technical cooperation projects under UNDP and other funding arrangements.
55. In order to implement these strategies and priorities in the 1999-2003 time-frame, the Development Sector proposes the following actions:
Full implementation of the "Valletta Action Plan"
Study of new Questions and continuation of some ongoing studies
Implementation of recommendations of development study groups endorsed by WTDC98
Organizing and encouraging participation of the private sector in BDT activities and promotion of partnerships
Mobilizing resources for development projects, particularly for LDCs
Increased cooperation with the other ITU Sectors and other organizations
Continued provision of information and publication of World and Regional Telecommunication Development Reports
Updating of existing and preparation of new handbooks/manuals for the use of developing countries
Continuing to execute technical cooperation projects.
56. The mission of the secretariat (meaning the General Secretariat and the three Bureaux) is to provide high quality, efficient services to the Union's membership and customers in response to the needs they have identified and within the limits of the resources made available by the membership.
57. The secretariat shares the environmental challenges, constraints and opportunities identified in part II above. The main challenge it faces is to maintain established standards of quality and efficiency while responding to steadily increasing service demands in an environment characterized by:
"zero-growth" in the financial resources derived from assessed contributions which finance the bulk of the Union's activities;
organizational and managerial rules derived from the United Nations common system;
a situation in which any significant undertaking beyond the responsibilities outlined in the Convention should be identified, approved specifically by the Council in advance and coordinated with the membership.
58. To address these challenges, the secretariat should follow these strategic objectives:
58.1 Efficiency, transparency, openness and customer service.
58.2 Quick, efficient and high-quality response to membership needs.
58.3 Develop a cadre of staff who have:
a shared view of the ITU's fundamental purposes;
a common understanding of the priorities of the Union as they may change from time to time;
a willingness and a capacity to act in concert, supporting one another in the achievement of departmental and organizational objectives;
a common organizational culture.
a customer orientation that includes responsiveness, efficiency, flexibility and accountability.
58.4 Instil an organizational climate:
that values diversity of cultures, backgrounds and opinions;
that supports risk taking;
in which delegation is encouraged and responsibility accepted;
in which communication and information flow are facilitated;
in which committees are properly used and decisions are taken by appropriate managers;
in which managers exercise flexibility and rules are used not to inhibit but to facilitate.
58.5 Build essential skills so that staff acquire the required competencies:
to exercise good interpersonal skills;
to function effectively in ambiguous situations;
to manage resources for the achievement of results.
58.6 Set objectives that move the organization forward in a time of great change so that:
all staff are evaluated and rewarded for the achievement of agreed objectives;
staff anticipate and manage change.
K. Priorities of the Secretariat
59. To achieve the above strategic objectives, the following priorities have been set for 1999-2003:
59.1 To improve the quality and efficiency of services provided to the ITU membership and the Union's other customers by:
using the cost attribution framework for ITU products and services which was created in response to the recommendations of ITU-2000 to develop a comprehensive set of quality, efficiency and productivity indicators for all ITU activities;
outsourcing products and services if the result is a net benefit to the Union's membership.
59.2 To improve the development and management of human resources by:
recruiting people with the skills required to serve the Union's members and customers in the new telecommunication environment, while paying attention to geographic and gender balance;
improving training policies and programmes for staff at all levels so that they have the competencies needed in the new environment and are fully prepared to assume new roles and responsibilities;
ensuring greater flexibility in the deployment of human resources to respond to emerging requirements and enrich career opportunities;
continuing to develop middle level and senior management skills in the secretariat.
59.3 To improve the management of secretariat resources through:
improvements to formal planning, management and reviewing systems;
greater delegation of authority to managers, with appropriate accountability and control mechanisms;
enhanced coordination between strategic, financial and performance management systems.
59.4 To adapt the secretariat's organizational culture to the new environment by:
continuing improvements to internal communication;
instilling a culture of customer service, entrepreneurship, accountability, recognition of performance and continuous learning.
59.5 To extend operational planning to the three Sectors and General Secretariat as a mechanism to enhance accountability and transparency and link this management tool to the strategic planning and budgeting process, given the symmetry required between the objectives and priority activities outlined in the strategic plan and the costing analysis of ITU products and services specified in the financial plan.