MOBILE, REGIONAL CARRIERS BRIDGE
DIGITAL DIVIDE
The digital divide is narrowing. It could do little else, with just one fixed
phone line per 100 inhabitants in 1995 (that's a whopping three today). But the
biggest surprise is the ultimate fill-in technology — mobile phones — and
means. New investments by regional carriers are picking up the slack from their
counterparts in richer countries that have all but abandoned their commitment to
telecommunications development in nations that still lack a basic
telecommunications infrastructure.
Mobile phone use in Africa has skyrocketed with cell phone subscribers
outnumbering those from fixed lines in countries like Morocco at an astonishing
six-to-one rate. Over 80% of all phone users in the Congo, Cameroon, Kenya and
Uganda do so from handsets. And mobile phone users more than tripled in Nigeria
to 1.5 million in just over a year. The continent leads the world in mobile
phone growth.
That surge suggests that fixed line access may morph into an outdated measure
of a maturing telecommunications infrastructure, and that follow-on services
like Internet access will likely focus on the roving handset, instead.
Worldwide, mobile phone users now outnumber fixed line ones with their numbers
in low-income countries surging to over 500 million today from 3 million in
1993, for the fastest take-up rates in the world.
Internet use is growing in emerging economies too, sometimes at rates
four-to-five times higher than earlier estimates due to unreported users using
free Web services, Internet cafes or prepaid cards. From 2001 to 2002, Internet
users in low-income countries more than doubled, for the highest global growth
rates. Sure, penetration still nudges a tiny 1%, but the burgeoning demand bodes
well for future growth.
But most remarkable of all are unexpected alliances among regional operators
to supply mostly mobile phone services in Africa, and the heretofore
unimaginable investments by, say, Asian operators and equipment makers in
far-flung African locales which Western carriers have, by-and-large, avoided.
The newcomers see the business case for being there.
Such trends, challenges and opportunities will be discussed at the World
Summit On the Information Society in Geneva from 10-12 December. The gathering,
organized by the International Telecommunication Union, brings together business
and political leaders to forge solutions focusing on nations with low to no
infrastructure and builds on recent successes in lower-income countries.
That bodes well for accelerated telecommunications take-up and continental
solutions to telecommunications shortcomings, and of course, an economic
spillover to the country providing the services or gear.
Take Mauritius, a French- and English- speaking island off east Africa. The
government of India (which falls into the low-income category), is injecting a
healthy USD 30 million into the new USD 100 million "Cyber City", the
island's answer to Silicon Valley. The project focuses on moving Mauritius
beyond its core sugar, tourism, textile and financial services industries into
new age markets, like software. Strong ethnic ties (nearly 70% of Mauritians are
of Indian descent) were a natural for India, which saw Mauritius as a stepping
stone to further business in Africa and Francophone countries.
Earlier efforts to diversify Mauritius's economy bore fruit in healthy annual
GDP growth of 5.9% between 1973 and 1999, earning the country the nickname
"African Tiger" and the fourth-highest per capita income in Africa.
South Africa's aggressive expansion in Africa is noteworthy, as well. Since
the last World Telecom, South African operator MTN has kickstarted mobile
telecommunications services in Uganda, Nigeria, Rwanda, Swaziland and Cameroon.
Trans-Africa services include mobile, broadband, fixed and payphone services in
the pre- and post-paid categories (one specialized South African application
tracks a runner's progress through add-on shoe chips for short-messaging times
to others. MTN even has a solar-powered phone in Uganda).
Vodacom, another South African cellular company, has set up mobile service in
Africa's third-largest country, the Democratic Republic of Congo, and in
Tanzania where its total investment tops USD 150 million (its claim to fame is
enabling mobile phone calls from Mt. Kilimanjaro).
Both have grabbed lucrative opportunities from giant European carriers in
retrenchment following the 3G fiasco and sluggish economic growth and which,
with their bloated inventories and soaring debt levels largely stayed away from
unsure spots. The newcomers' trump card includes better knowledge of the local
culture, plus the extra efforts they provide for deals that would be considered
chump change to behemoths.
But those businesses make money. Even in the turmoil of war or economic
upheaval, communication is key. Mobile phones continued to grow in the
Democratic Republic of Congo despite ongoing civil war.
"They know the environment and how to make profits there," says
Michael Minges, acting head of the Market, Economics and Finance Unit within the
Telecommunications Development arm of the ITU, a UN organization that focuses on
telecommunications regulation and development. He sees such
"South-South" deals driving telecommunications access growth in
underserved regions over the coming years. "The developed nations lost the
will to invest and are out of touch with local markets. Regional operators are
stepping in and filling the gap".
Asia, too, has produced some eyebrow raising tie-ups on its technological
lead and low-cost manufacturing might. Singapore Telecom has bought into
operators in both Indonesia and Australia; Malaysia Telekom's stakes in South
Africa and Guineau are noteworthy.
Asian gear makers have also stepped up to the plate through deals like
Huawei's sale of mobile gear to Nigeria. China can thank Ericsson and Nokia,
which built a strong manufacturing base at China's insistence - for teaching
them the trade.
"The Japanese and Koreans are coming on strong. The Korean government
knew its broadband lead would spill over into exports," says the ITU's
Minges. "This technological lead gives Asian companies an advantage over
European and North American equipment vendors."
But much remains to be done. Africa's robust growth leads that of Latin
America and the former Soviet republics between Telecom 1995 and 1999, but its
jaw-droppingly low penetration rate still leaves a yawning void. Under 3% of all
Africans can access telecommunications of any kind with virtually all those
outside urban areas unable to access fixed lines. The Internet is out of reach
to the vast majority of Africans.
That's why international organizations like the ITU make communication
services everywhere a top priority.
And for most developing countries broadband - which sports single digit
penetration in wealthy countries like Japan and the US anyway - remains a
distant dream. But the economic benefits of broadband, like speeding small
business development, are undisputable.
That's shifting the definition of Digital Divide. It increasingly focuses on
high-speed Internet access as an essential economic growth driver rather than
basic voice services which lagged even in 1980s Europe, when the idea of
universal telecommunications access first took root in a celebrated report
called "The Missing Link". The dual roles of affordability and
education in luring in new subscribers have taken front stage, as well,
particularly in impoverished and remote areas of high-income countries.
There are success stories. Bhutan's Internet push through access at post
offices allows users to dip their toe in the Internet; Philippinos send a
whopping 75 million text messages a day.
"A low-tech solution can be great," explains William Hahn, an
analyst at market research firm Gartner.
That's pushing business and international organizations to push for broadband
in selected regions like South Africa and Uganda, as well, where fixed phone
access demand has posted progress. Tele-medecine, for example, is really only
feasible over a high-speed connection so that doctors across the world can work
together in real-time.
"The gap is today is more one of quality," explains Minges.
"Without enough bandwidth you can't send files at high-speed or
videoconference for tele-education or tele-medecine.'
Telecenters with Internet access, and text messaging over mobile phones
allows countries just coming online to get their feet wet on the web, often from
devices they already have. As the first to reach the phone customer, mobile
operators are eager to leverage that mindshare through feasible and affordable
rural offerings that will carry over into follow-on services with higher
margins. Revenue per user for broadband services is often much higher than for
regular Internet use.
New wireless technologies like Wi-Fi, which are less costly and easier to
install than copper now make rural Internet services feasible. Public access
points using such infrastructure can be profitable at revenues of as little as
USD 5 a day.
The government's role in driving both telecommunications and Internet buy in
also a priority for both the private and public sectors. Experience shows that
if an administration truly gets behind a project and backs it up with compelling
content and resources, demand can be robust.
South Korea leads the world in household broadband penetration, largely
because its government spearheaded efforts to boost infrastructure and use
through loans and tax cuts for gear makers and spurred the creation of
cybercafes to boost Internet literacy.
Developing nation governments realize that Internet use is most likely to
come from such centers. (Around 80% of surfers in Peru, for example, do so from
Internet cafes). ITU members have thus asked the ITU to measure subscribers from
such public access points.
In Venezuela, prepaid cards helped drive the country's mobile phone
penetration rates to one of the highest in Latin America.
Such pay-as-you go plans lure in many more users in emerging economies than
the monthly subscriptions popular in higher-income countries.
Privatization of the world's former incumbent operators (over half are now
fully or partly privatized) also plays a role in bridging the digital divide.
New entrants can provide sought-after services like Internet access that the
government-owned operators resisted to keep their voice cash-cows intact.
Teledensity in Nigeria grew fourfold, for example, when the government gave
the green light to three new mobile carriers.
For businesses eyeing the exploding business opportunity in emerging
economies the ITU helps pave the way for investment by imparting invaluable
information about local laws and regulatory conditions, the key role of
involving the community and opportunities and challenges for new carriers.
Equally important for telecommunications development is a regulatory body to
oversee those new services, ensure competitive costs and offerings, and resolve
disputes when operators overstep.
The ITU plays a critical role in spurring such regulatory reform, through
guidance in its reports like its soon-to-be-released "Trends in
Telecommunication Reform: Promoting Universal Access to Information
Communication Technologies". The guide highlights innovative financial
vehicles for infrastructure build-out in rural areas (such as Colombia's USD 100
million rural telecommunications development project), effective pricing
strategies and grassroots and small business efforts to bridge the digital
divide, like the Grameen Bank's oft-cited handset rental scheme.
The organization also helps spur such growth through seminars and workshops
focusing on subjects like tariffs and interconnectivity, appropriate technology
and universal access.
But the landscape is still a long way from being level. "The incumbents
are digging themselves into a broadband rut," says Hahn.
There is good news: Since 2002 thirteen countries have created such
regulatory bodies (over a quarter in Africa); today there are over 120 such
regulatory agencies, up from 13 in 1993.
In parallel over half of around 200 operators are now fully or partly
privatized; another quarter have opened up their markets in some way by allowing
in fixed, international or mobile operators. New shareholders now hold operators
accountable, as well.
Failed attempts at selling off stakes in Australia, Bulgaria, the Czech
Republic, Costa Rica, and the Ukraine will likely bear fruits in the future.
The future does look bright. Twenty-five countries say they want to sell at
least part of their fully- or partially-owned operators.
ITU TELECOM WORLD 2003 Forum
The ITU TELECOM WORLD 2003 Forum, which takes
place in Geneva, Switzerland from October 12-18, will include more discussion
and debate associated with industry growth, business models, investment
strategies for developing nations and broadband technology: Sessions that focus
on the Digital Divide are as follows:
- Sunday, October 12: "Helping the World Communicate", from 10 to
12:30
- Monday, October 13: "Is market liberalization working?" from
9.00 to 10.30
- Monday, October 13: "Investment Strategies" from 11.00 to 12.30
- Monday, October 13: "Regulating for the future" from 14.30 to
16.00
- Tuesday, October 14, "ICTs for Development: Public Internet
Access", from 09:00 to 12:30
- Tuesday, October 14: "Relevant technologies for the developing
world" from 11.00 to 12.30
- Tuesday, October 14: "Universal Access: Promoting Digital
Opportunities for All", from 14:30-16:00
- Tuesday, October 14: "Opening up trade in telecoms" from 16.30
to 18.00
- Wednesday, October 15: "New local presence in the developing
world" from 14.30 to 16.00
- Wednesday, October 15: "Human Capital Development", from 14.30
to 16.00
- Thursday, October 16: "Workshop on Telemedicine", from 10 to
12:30
- Friday, October 17, "The World Summit on the Information
Society", from 9:30-12:00
All sessions are at the Geneva Palexpo. For more information on ITU TELECOM
WORLD 2003, please visit: http://www.itu.int/WORLD2003/
Spokespeople available for interview
Please contact Kathleen Maksymec or Andreas Keller to arrange an interview on
this topic with an ITU spokesperson:
- Kathleen Maksymec: +41 79 312 8975
- Andreas Keller: +41 22 761 3353
|